🏡 View Complete Property Details
Village Living Never Goes Out of Style: Explore 37 Fuller Avenue Webster NY 14580
Some communities grow larger without losing their identity. Webster is one of them.
Tucked along the southern shore of Lake Ontario, Webster has grown into one of Monroe County’s most desirable places to call home while preserving the charm of a traditional hometown. Its historic village center remains the heart of the community, where locally owned restaurants, cafés, shops, community events and generations of residents continue to gather. It is this balance of small-town character and modern convenience that continues to attract homeowners year after year.
Just a few blocks from the center of it all sits 37 Fuller Avenue Webster NY 14580—a quiet residential street that perfectly reflects the enduring appeal of Webster Village. This unique location combines the tranquility of suburban living with easy access to the vibrant life of Webster.
Discover the charm and convenience of living at 37 Fuller Avenue Webster NY 14580, where your suburban lifestyle meets community warmth.
Our Personal Insights
One of the things I appreciate most about Webster is that it still feels like a hometown.
While many suburban communities have expanded into busy commercial corridors, Webster has managed to preserve the personality that makes village living so appealing. Fuller Avenue sits just two blocks south of historic Main Street (Ridge Road) and only a short walk from South Avenue, placing residents within easy reach of local restaurants, coffee shops, ice cream, neighborhood shopping and community events without ever needing to drive.
The street itself feels like it belongs to another era. Mature trees, sidewalks on both sides of the road and classic lampposts create an inviting streetscape that encourages evening walks and conversations with neighbors. Developed during Webster’s early and mid-century growth, the neighborhood is made up primarily of well-maintained Cape Cods, Ranches and Colonials, each with its own personality and history.
This is one of those neighborhoods where children still ride bicycles, neighbors wave from their front porches and people genuinely enjoy walking to the Village for dinner, coffee or one of Webster’s many seasonal festivals.
Those kinds of neighborhoods never seem to go out of style.
Living in Webster
Location has always been one of Webster Village’s greatest strengths.
From Fuller Avenue, Spry Middle School is located at the end of the street, while State Road Elementary is also within close proximity. Webster’s historic village offers an excellent variety of locally owned restaurants, cafés, boutiques and neighborhood businesses that continue to give the community its distinctive character.
Just a mile away, Holt Road and Hard Road provide virtually every modern convenience, including Wegmans, Towne Center at Webster, medical offices, fitness centers and national retailers.
Outdoor recreation is equally impressive. Webster Park, North Ponds Park and the Webster Parks & Recreation facilities are all nearby, while the shoreline of Lake Ontario offers beaches, hiking trails, fishing and spectacular sunsets just a few miles north.
For commuters, Route 104 provides quick access to downtown Rochester in approximately fifteen minutes, while nearby Penfield, Fairport and the surrounding countryside offer scenic drives, family farms and seasonal farm markets that continue to define eastern Monroe County.
It is this combination of historic village charm, outdoor recreation and everyday convenience that has made Webster one of the area’s most sought-after communities.
At a Glance
Address: 37 Fuller Avenue, Webster, NY 14580
Asking Price: $329,000
MLS: R1704004
Style: Cape Cod
Year Built: 1941
Living Area: 1,648 SF
Lot Size: 0.35 Acres
Bedrooms: 3
Full Baths: 2
Half Baths: None
Basement: Full, Unfinished
Garage: Detached 2-Car
Total Taxes: $6,017
School District: Webster Central School District
Highlights: First-Floor Bedrooms & Full Bath • Spacious Primary Suite • Private Balcony • 3-Season Room • Wood-Burning Fireplace • Covered Deck • Detached Garage • Shed • Walk to Webster Village • Numerous Recent Updates
Listing courtesy of The Angie Flack Brown Team – Keller Williams Realty Greater Rochester.
The Angie Flack Brown Team is proud to represent the seller of this property.
What We Love About 37 Fuller Avenue
Perfectly positioned within the Village of Webster, this inviting Cape Cod offers the kind of warmth and character that immediately feels like home.
Beautiful curb appeal welcomes you with attractive landscaping and a handsome new front entry before opening to rich hardwood floors throughout the first floor. The spacious living room is filled with natural light from a substantial bay window and is anchored by a classic wood-burning fireplace with a carved mantel and tile hearth.
The dining room connects comfortably to both the kitchen and the enclosed three-season room, creating inviting spaces for everyday living and entertaining. The kitchen features abundant hickory cabinetry, charming glass-front cabinets, updated appliances and exceptional storage.
Two first-floor bedrooms and a full bath provide the flexibility of first-floor living or comfortable guest and office space.
Upstairs, the entire second floor becomes an expansive primary suite complete with a sitting area, walk-in closet and private bath featuring a soaking tub and a new glass-enclosed shower. One of the home’s most delightful surprises is the private second-floor balcony overlooking the backyard—a peaceful retreat rarely found in homes of this style.
Outside, beautifully maintained landscaping, a two-car garage, storage shed and a covered outdoor dining area tucked beneath the garage overhang create wonderful opportunities to enjoy Western New York’s warmer months.
Important updates include:
Furnace (2010)
Tear-off roof (2018)
All new Andersen windows (2024)
New front and storm doors (2023)
Comfortable, welcoming and exceptionally well located, this is one of those homes that simply feels right from the moment you arrive.
According to Angie…
Some homes immediately put you at ease the moment you walk through the front door, and this is certainly one of them. Add the opportunity to walk into Webster Village for dinner, coffee or community events, and you have something that is becoming increasingly difficult to find—a home that offers both comfort and genuine neighborhood connection.
Some homes immediately put you at ease the moment you walk through the front door, and this is certainly one of them. Add the opportunity to walk into Webster Village for dinner, coffee or community events, and you have something that is becoming increasingly difficult to find—a home that offers both comfort and genuine neighborhood connection.
Thinking About Buying or Selling in Webster?
If you’re considering buying or selling in Webster, The Angie Flack Brown Team can help you understand neighborhood values, compare market opportunities, and make confident real estate decisions backed by decades of local experience.
From waterfront neighborhoods to classic pre-war communities like Fuller Avenue, we’re here to help you discover what makes every corner of Rochester unique.